My Name Is  B.S Gupta
I Am An Advocate.
The Two Communities
Who Live In India
The Majority One Holds 80% Of Hindus And
The Minority One Holds 20% Of Muslims
There Is A Perception Which Can
Be Right Or Wrong Between Two.
That Is " Islam Was
Spread By The Sword"
Whether It Is A Historical
Fact Or Myth Can'T Be Said.
But Is It True That 3000 To 6000 Tamples
Were Demolished And Turned Into Mosques?
Is It True That Especially
During The Reign Of Aurangzeb
Hundreds Of Thousands Were Converted
To Islam From Hindu By Force?
Number: Two
I Am Asking A Question
Today'S Context
There Is A Marriage Act For Hindus
Excluding Muslim And Christian Other
Religions Are Included In It.
Don’T You Want To Say That All Of Muslims
Should Be Included In The Hindu Marriage Act.
To Make A Common Civil Court From Taking Good Things From The
Both Religions Being Changed The Current Hindu Marriage Act.
One Thing I Understand
Will And Bequest (Wasaya) In Islamic Law
No One Can Make A Will More Than
One-Third Of One'S Property To Someone.
I Want For Hindus This Law
Under A Common Civil Court.
It Is Not Like That It Is Only For Muslims Not For Hindus If
The Hindu Marriage Act Is Changed To Indian Marriage Act.
I Like This One Most In Islam.
Why Don'T Muslims Come Forward
For A Uniform Civil Court?
Please Tell Me The Reason.
Brother Asked Three Questions
In One Question.
Question Number 1: From The History
Whether Islam Was Spread By The Sword,
He Was Asking Me That Isn'T It Reality About
Demolishing More Than 3000 Temples
To Build Mosques And Killing
Of Hundreds Of Thousands?
This Is Absolutely
Fake And Hoax.
I Can Say That A Few Temples
Might Have Demolished.
I Am Not Saying That No
Temple Was Demolished.
Maybe So Called Muslim Who
Called Them Muslims By Name Only,
They Could Have Demolished A Few
Temples And Made Mosques There.
Could Be....
But Saying About Demolishing 3000 To
6000 Temples Is Totally Baseless And False.
Some Muslim Kings
Could Have Done Wrong.
You Can'T Blame Islam
For That Reason.
As Hitler Killed 6 Million
Jews Burning Alive
Can I Tell That Christianity
Is Bad For That Reason?
Absolutely Baseless.
But Islam Does..?
Was It Written In Bibles?
Like This, It Is
Only A Propaganda.
A Few Temples Might
Have Demolished.
I Can'T Say That No Temple
Was Demolished.
But Medias Are Fuelling This Small Issue And
Books Are Being Written On This Subject.
You Can See Tipu Sultan..
Now, They Are Against Tipu Sultan...
At Present If You Go To Mysore, You See
Temples In The Precinct Of Tipu Sultan.
If You Say 3000 To 6000 Temples Were
Demolished, How Could You Be Alive?
You Are Talking About Killing Of Hundreds
Of Thousands, How Could You Be Alive?
Your Aliveness Gives Witness That
Islam Wasn’T Spread By The Sword.
If It Had Been Truth
Hundreds Of Thousands People Were Killed
Some People Might
Have Been Killed,
There Are Black Sheep In
Every Religion And Community.
He / She Is Liable For That Not Religion.
You Will See Some Bad People In Islam,
Christianity And Hinduism As Well.
You Can See, In India, Some Muslims Are
Dealing In Drugs But It Is Forbidden In Islam.
You Should Blame Them
But Not The Islam.
The Way You Are Saying, Hundreds Of
Thousands People Were Killed Is Baseless.
A Few People Might Have Been Killed.
In My Talk, I Said That More
Than 80% Of Non-Muslim In India
Give Witness That Islam
Didn’T Force With The Sword.
Why Did Those People Spare You?
Are You Relative To Them?
Why Were You Spared?
Why Did They Spare 800
Millions Non-Muslims?
They Had Power, Ruled For 1000 Years,
Could Have Converted Everyone To Islam.
It Implies That Islam
Wasn’T Spread By The Sword.
Many Non-Muslims Accepted Islam
After Being Pleased With Islam.
Saying It Is Completely Wrong.
Your Second Question:
What Shoud We Do?
One Civil Court Should
Be For Everyone.
From The Good Things Of All Religions
That Civil Should Be Formed.
I Agree With You Entirely.
Mightbe Other Muslims Are
Against You But I Am With You.
Why?
Why Am I With You?
First One,
If We, Muslims Know About
Other Religions....
Whenever The Matter Of The Common Civil Comes,
Most Of Them Claim That Muslims Are Wrong.
It Is Not Possible. .
Why? There Are Many Different
Jurisprudences In Hinduism In India.
It Is Not Possilbe,
Only 20% Of People Are Muslims,
But Not Possilbe In The 80% Of Hindus
Because Of Differences In Hinduism, Hindus
Can’T Follow The Common Civil Court..
Different Rules Are Of Different
Sects For Man And Woman In Hinduism.
It Is Impossible To Cross It.
I Am Saying To It.
It Is A Matter Of Regret That We Muslims Don’T
Know It And No Need For Us To Talk For It.
It Is Just Whining ...
Point Number 1,
Point Number 2,
Suppose, All Of You Agreed That There
Should Be A Common Civil Court.
"All Good Things From The Four
Major Religions Should Be Taken"
Absolutely Right.
My First Question
Show Me One Thing Which Is Against
Humanity In Islam, We Will Remove That.
Your Saying On The Good Things Of
Other Religions Is Completely Right.
For An Example, I Gave A Talk On The
Similarity Between Hinduism And Islam.
So Good Things From
Hinduism I Took.
Similarity Between Islam And
Christianity, I Took Good Things.
Tell Me The One Thing
Which Is Bad In Islam
That Would Be Removed Then..
I Will Come If There Is Any Debate
On That At The Stage, In Sha Allah.
What We Will Do, We Will Take
Good Things From All Religions.
In Sha Allah I Will Come To
The Stage On Behalf Of Islam.
It Is A Challenge
I Can Debate On That With
Any One From Any Background
In Sha Allah, As I Am Student Of Comparative
Religion (Islam And Other Religons)
I Insist There
Should Be A Debate.
If Any Truth Come Out From
This Should Be Acted Upon It.
The Thing Which Is The Best For
Humanity Should Be Followed.
For That Reason, The Final Revelation
(The Quran) Given By Allah (Swt)
Is The Best Book For Humanity
And Should Be Followed.
Your Third Question
Under Hindu Narrative....
Under Islam We Can Donate One Third Of Property
As A Charity, But It Is Not Compulsory.
Islamic Will Is Based On The
Quran (Surah Nisa Ch.4 V.11-12 And 176)
These Says
Concerning Your Children: The Share Of
The Male Is Like That Of Two Females.
If The Deceased Has Any Offspring, Each Of His
Parents Shall Have A Sixth Of The Inheritance;
And If The Deceased Has No Child And His Parents Alone
Inherit Him, Then One-Third Shall Go To His Mother
In The Verse 12.
And For You Is Half Of What Your
Wives Leave If They Have No Child,
But If They Have A Child, For You
Is One Fourth Of What They Leave,
And For The Wives Is One
Fourth If You Leave No Child.
But If You Leave A Child, Then For
Them Is An Eighth Of What You Leave,
It Is Difficult To Keep In Mind.
You Can Check Out References.
Surah An-Nisa V.11-12.
After That
You Make A Will For
One-Third Of Your Property To Someone
But This Bequest Should
Not For These People.
To Give More Property To Your Elder Son Out
Of Affection Is Totally Wrong In Islam.
You Make A Will For One-Third Of Your Property
To Someone Who Doesn’T Come To Your Inheritance.
You Said You Like It Most.
You Want To Do It.
Who Stops You?
Under Indian Law, None Can Stop You To Donate
One-Third Of Your Property To Someone.
Niether Me Nor Minster...
If You Want To Follow
The True Religion,
You Can Accept Islam.
We Welcome You.
