Hi I’m John Green and this is Crash Course
European History.
So, World War I unleashed seemingly endless
violence.
But while it was happening, even more violence
was taking shape across Europe, most notably
the Russian revolution and civil war.
[Intro]
The failure of Tsar Nicholas II’s government
in directing the war effort caused immense
suffering.
He built no efficient administration to ensure
adequate weaponry, or transportation, or food,
or medical care, or the other necessities
of modern warfare.
I know we often like to make fun of bureaucracy,
but governments without it tend to … fail
miserably.
So even though Russian soldiers were loyal
and effective fighters, they suffered from
a lack of basic materials--like bullets, for
instance, and soldiers often went without
boots, wearing rags on their feet.
Some generals were first rate but others were
totally uninstructed in modern techniques
and more concerned with conducting pogroms
against their own Jewish troops than effectively
fighting the enemy.
As hundreds of thousands of wounded people
and millions of refugees crossed back into
an entirely unprepared Russia from 1915 on,
soldiers deserted while civilian organizations
picked up where the imperial administration
failed.
Local organizations called zemstvos took responsibility
for civilian well-being, joining other groups
to take care of the wounded and maintain the
home front more generally.
And throughout history, when people see such
groups doing the work that governments traditionally
do, it can deeply undermine support for governments.
On the warfront, the government wasn’t much
more inspirational.
After a string of Russian defeats, Czar Nicholas
decided that he should personally oversee
the battlefront, which made him appear incompetent--because,
you know, to be fair, he was--and also he
seemed uninterested in the survival of ordinary
Russians--which, again, you could make the
case.
All of this meant that a revolution was around
the corner.
But before we get there, I think the center
of the world just opened.
CAT CALENDAR: We explain that Russia would
soon adopt the calendar used in Europe and
the United States, but at the time, was still
using a somewhat different calendar, which
is why the International Women’s Day we
are about to refer to happened in Russian
February and American March.
Because dates are not very important, we are
not going to overanalyze this, but everyone
should use the exact same calendar--specifically,
this cat calendar.
It’s a calendar!
And it’s not just any calendar, it’s our
editorial director Meredith’s vintage cats
calendar.
So shortly, Russia would adopt this calendar,
the one used in Europe and the United States.
But at the time, it was still using a somewhat
different calendar, which is why the International
Women’s Day we are about to talk about happened
in Russian February, and not American March.
Now because the memorization of dates is overrated,
we are not going to overanalyze this, but
for the record, everyone should use the exact
same calendar all the time, specifically this
vintage cat calendar.
OK.
So, on Russian February 23, 1917 it was International
Women’s Day.
Working women took to the streets of Petrograd--oh,
god I feel another explanation coming on.
(OK, Petrograd had been St. Petersburg, but
that sounded too German, so they made it Petrograd.
But soon it would be Leningrad, only eventually
to become St. Petersburg again).
Right, so it’s February, sort of, and we’re
in Petrograd, sort of.
The important thing is that these women were
protesting the effects of a totally mismanaged
war effort: soaring inflation, food scarcity,
casualties in the millions, and an army often
defeated and in retreat.
Protests surged in the capital and then traveled
the empire.
Rebellious soldiers and the persistence of
angry crowds along with the insistence of
his wider family eventually persuaded Nicholas
to abdicate his throne.
Members of the Duma—the assembly of elected
representatives that Nicholas very reluctantly
set up to end the revolution of 1905--constituted
themselves as a Provisional Government, consisting
of monarchist, conservative, liberal, and
a variety of socialist members.
Both disorder and new forms of organization
unfolded.
Workers and soldiers revived the councils,
or “soviets,” they had used during the
revolution of 1905 and began claiming a large
voice in ruling Russia.
And as wealthy leaders of the Provisional
Government and the less privileged members
of the soviets jostled for administrative
supremacy, wartime chaos accelerated in Russian
cities—especially in Petrograd,
where soldiers and workers shot opponents,
including random officials and military officers,
because they stood for the oppression and
starvation of the old regime.
This competition for power on the homefront
coexisted with general support for World War
I, which itself brought more death and more
deprivation, which further weakened government
and other institutions.
Still some were optimistic that life would
change for the better or as one poet put it
“that our false, filthy, boring, hideous
life should become a just, pure, merry, and
beautiful life.”
Peasants confiscated some noble estates, while
rank-and-file soldiers ended the degrading
deference they had traditionally shown to
aristocratic officers.
And to some, equality and an expansion of
rights felt imminent.
In April 1917, the Germans organized Bolshevik
leader Vladimir Lenin’s passage from exile
in Switzerland back to Russia.
Bolsheviks, breaking with Marx’s idea of
the working-class spearheading revolutionary
change, believed that an elite cadre of leaders
needed to lead the revolution.
Once Lenin returned to Russia, he began making
public speeches and declared a platform of
“Peace, Bread, Land,” an explicit rejection
of continuing the war, and also the kind of
populist slogan that deeply appealed to hungry,
landless, and war-weary people.
Lenin, along with another Bolshevik leader,
Leon Trotsky, helped make the Bolsheviks stand
out with their publicity and grass-roots organizing
in factories and among soldiers.
And the pair craftily altered their own positions
as the wind blew, sometimes appearing to agree
with the soviets or certain provisional government
positions and at other times calling for violence
and an end to the democratic politics that
most middle-of-the-roaders and other socialists
wanted.
For Lenin, it was violence alone that would
bring about an overthrow of the old and the
creation of a new, Bolshevik society.
Only deliberately inflicted bloodshed would
crush the aspirations for a democratic Russia.
In the summer of 1917, charismatic lawyer
Alexander Kerensky came to head the Provisional
Government with the aim of reviving Russia’s
capacity to fight in World War I.
But the effort ultimately failed.
The government, targeted by Bolshevik propaganda
and organizing, had grown fatally weak.
Let’s go to the Thought Bubble.
1.
By the fall, Lenin determined the time was
right to overthrow the Provisional Government
2. and with it the mixture of democratic policies
espoused by the hodge-podge of politicians,
3.
including various kinds of socialists, and
anarchists, and constitutional monarchists,
and liberals who sought rights and the rule
of law.
4.
Lenin didn’t believe the revolution could
proceed via peaceful change or negotiation
with all these various leaders;
5.
instead, he insisted on the use of violence
against them and rejected peaceful change
or negotiation.
6.
In October 1917, the Bolsheviks led a coup
at a meeting of the Soviets,
7. taking over government buildings, arms
depots, transportation networks, and other
infrastructure.
8.
The party then endorsed elections to a Constituent
Assembly that met in January 1918.
9.
The Bolsheviks won only a minority of the
seats
10.
but forced the dismissal of the Assembly before
it could be constituted as a government.
11.
The Bolsheviks then developed a tactic meant
to destroy, in the words of one, “constitutional
illusions.”
12.
They imprisoned and murdered advocates for
democracy, and constitutions, and freedom
of political expression by the tens and eventually
the hundreds of thousands.
13.
And as they took control, the Bolsheviks shuttered
local institutions such as zemstvos.
14.
They nationalized industries and banks
15. and by late 1917, began seeking a negotiated
withdrawal from the war.
16.
The Germans offered only the draconian Treaty
of Brest-Litovsk,
17. which gave Russia’s western holdings
to Germany.
18.
Lenin initia1lly called the German offer “obscene.”
19.
But as the Central Powers continued their
advance through Russian territory,
20. he finally accepted the treaty.
Thanks Thought Bubble.
So by this time, the Russian capital of Petrograd/St.
Petersburg had been moved to Moscow because
German troops had gotten too close.
Lenin believed that an imminent uprising of
Europe’s entire working class would overturn
the entire Brest-Litovsk settlement anyway,
and restore Russia’s original boundaries,
although he ultimately rejected his initial
faith in worldwide revolution, settling instead
for “socialism in one country.”
That said, the Bolsheviks did want to promote
and control the rise of Communist parties
elsewhere, so they established the Communist
International or Comintern in 1919.
Brest-Litovsk was a turning point for many,
including those who were ready to continue
fighting for a Russian victory in World War
I. Dissident generals received volunteers
from an array of those who feared the rise
of the Bolsheviks, from monarchists and liberals
to other kinds of socialists.
And we’re emphasizing the diversity of beliefs
here, to show that Bolshevism was just one
of many responses--some radical, some moderate--to
the dysfunction and deprivation of early 20th
century Russia.
But at any rate, these diverse non-Bolshevik
groups were united primarily by their dislike
of the Bolsheviks, who by this time had rejected
the word “socialist” in favor of a new
party name: Communist.
Bolsheviks felt the socialists in Russia and
elsewhere were just too reform-minded, and
compromise-oriented, and pro-democracy.
And so eventually, Civil War broke out, and
until 1922, Russia and a good part of eastern
Europe were wracked with violence, and disease,
and famine, and starvation.
The Bolshevik dictatorship and its “Red
Terror” battled the so-called “White Movement,”
which even in its name defined itself primarily
by its opposition to the Bolshevik Reds.
Meanwhile, in areas like Ukraine, the Baltic
States, and Central Asia, people were seeking
independence from Russia, although in many
places, the independence movements were themselves
also divided by beliefs around the role the
state should play in the lives of its citizens,
whether democracy was compatible with a strong
state, and whether businesses should be government-held
or privately run.
The Bolsheviks took advantage of these divisions
both by taking on factions individually and
by pitting them against each other.
As Trotsky simultaneously built a loyal “Red”
army and as the newly created “Chekha”
or secret police picked off opponents, the
“Whites” were eventually defeated.
Not only was the White movement disunited
in its goals, they especially lacked a brilliantly
brutal leader like Lenin or an organizational
talent like Trotsky.
The Communist society the Bolsheviks established
was far different from the one envisioned
by the Marxist socialists of the nineteenth
century.
It was to be led by an elite, according to
Lenin’s plan, not by workers.
In fact, the Bolsheviks crushed a “green”
opposition from peasants who were angry about
the army confiscating their grain, which the
Bolsheviks justified as necessary for “War
Communism.”
The Bolsheviks also executed sailors at Kronstadt
who objected to the growing privileges of
the Bolshevik elite.
But instead of the state “withering away”
after a workers’ revolution as Marx had
predicted, the Bolshevik state became ever
more powerful, albeit with the support of
many in the population.
Beginning with Lenin, It inflicted perpetual
violence on its own people, inventing constant
threats from civilian “enemies.”
Lenin believed such violence was key not just
to establishing a Bolshevik state, but also
to maintaining one.
In 1922, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics
was declared.
Up and coming Bolshevik activist Joseph Stalin
helped forge this federation from the ethnic
groups of the former Russian empire.
The USSR supposedly fulfilled a Bolshevik
promise to more than 100 ethnicities of the
old Russian empire that they might retain
their culture, and language, and other local
ways.But to say those promises would not always
be kept would be something of an understatement.
Big challenges loomed for the Bolsheviks even
after these triumphs.
Industrial production had fallen to 13 percent
of its prewar level The death toll of the
civil war and the accompanying disease and
famine is estimated at 10 million.
Still, the postwar Bolshevik propaganda machine
thrived, drawing in people enthusiastic about
the idea of a workers’ paradise, and in
some cases, real progress was made.
The strapped government set up health clinics
and daycare centers so that everyone could
work to revive the economy.
The daughter of an imperial general Aleksandra
Kollontai oversaw the welfare system and wrote
easy-to-read novels about the wholesome relationships
between men and women under communism.
Communist enthusiasts taught rural people
to read, and proselytized to make Muslim communities
adopt what Bolsheviks interpreted as “modern”
ways--a reminder that not all missionaries
are religious.
Pioneering filmmaker Sergei Eisenstein produced
classic celebrations of ordinary people such
as “Battleship Potemkin” which is about
a bunch of sailors’ rebelling against tsarist
brutality.
But it’s inaccurate to imagine the Bolshevik
revolution led to some immediate and total
Communism.
In fact, in 1921 Lenin declared the New Economic
Policy in which elements of capitalism such
as individual businesses would be allowed
to help boost productivity.
Communist entrepreneurs were encouraged to
“grow rich” and wealth became valued.
So-called NEP-men flourished as did women
dripping in jewels and furs.
It was one more compromise the Bolsheviks
made as a temporary means to the end of domination.
Beginning in 1922, Lenin suffered a series
of strokes that eventually killed him in January
1924.
Joseph Stalin organized and led a lavish funeral,
handing out minor roles to other Bolsheviks
and sidelining his rival Trotsky, who would
go on to be murdered via ice axe to the face
at Stalin’s order.
We’ll get to that and much more when Crash
Course returns to Soviet Russia in two weeks.
Thanks for watching.
I’ll see you then.
