- Hi, I'm Gareth.
And in this video I'm
going to answer a question
that a lot of people have asked us.
Fundamental this,
"What is the difference
between 2/4 and 4/4?"
Okay well let's have a
think about time signatures
for a brief moment.
As many people will know the upper number
in a time signature, in this case the two
or in this case the four,
the upper number tells you how many beats
there are in a bar.
And the bottom number tells you
what kind of beats they are.
So for now if you're happy to accept
that four at the bottom
means the beats are crotchets
or quarter notes, if you've
learnt it in that system.
Then 2/4 means there are
two crotchet beats in a bar.
Two quarter note beats in a bar.
4/4 means that there are
four crotchet beats in a bar,
or four quarter note beats in a bar.
So, why might people be
asking what the difference is
because it's pretty
obvious isn't it, really?
This one's got two beats in a bar
that one's got four beats in a bar.
But this is what lies behind the question.
I can play a piece of music
and it would sound more
or less the same whether it's in 2/4 time
or 4/4 time.
So if I play this I could think
One
Two
One
Two
One
Two
One
Two
Or I could think,
One
Two
Three
Four
One
Two
Three
Four
Because it's possible to
count it either way, isn't it?
So if I notate that rhythm in 2/4
the rhythm I have just
played goes like this.
It's not a complicated rhythm.
But that's what I've just played.
And there's the end of it.
So, you can see exactly where
these two beats are coming.
There's the first, there's the second,
there's the first, there's the second,
there's the first, this one is split into
these two eighth notes, two quavers.
And on the last note I've got two beats.
But of course I can write
the same thing in 4/4.
So let's put the same rhythm down.
So this time it looks like this.
Exactly as it did before,
but you'll notice we haven't
got as many bar lines.
And why is that?
Because now we've got
four beats in each bar.
So you can see how that works.
So, really the sound of it, at face value,
is no different.
The rhythm's just the same,
it doesn't change the speed.
So how would you know
what the difference is
between the 2/4 and the 4/4?
Well it boils down to this,
it's a question of accentuation.
Because in music we have strong beats
and we have weak beats.
Or you might say we have
stronger beats and weaker beats.
In two time we go
strong
weak
strong
weak
strong
weak
strong
weak
Okay?
So If I play it in 2/4 time
it should sound like this.
Strong
weak
strong
weak
strong
weak
strong
weak
Now I'm over emphasising that,
it's not very subtle is it?
But it can be done in a very subtle way
so you just feel the first
beats of the bar being stronger
than the second beats in the bar.
It's one thing that
makes music interesting.
If you put equal weight on
every single beat of the music
it tends to sound rather
heavy, ponderous stuff.
So it's a good thing to think about
when you're performing music.
Actually where do the stresses want to be?
So in 2/4 we're putting the
stress on the first beat.
We're using the second
beat as a kind of lift
onto the next first beat.
So we get strong weak,
strong weak,
actually it's much more expressive.
Now if we're in four time.
Well we're going to have the same idea
that we're going to put the stress on the
first beat of the bar.
So I'm going to have a stress
there and a stress there.
So the difference here is of course,
we've only got half
the number of stresses.
Half the number of beat ones in 4/4
that we have in 2/4.
There's also a kind of hierarchy here
because in 4/4 time after the first beat
the next strongest beat is the third beat.
So, if you really get
organised in 4/4 time
you give us a strong
beat on beat number one
and then you do something
that's a little bit
sort of half strong on beat number three.
So you've got a sense of second
and fourth beats being lighter.
So if we just put the emphasis
on the first beat for now
We get
one
two
three
four
one
two
three
four
That makes it very clear.
If I do a little bit of
the half stress on three.
One
two
three
four
one
two
three
four
You can feel that we've got main stress
and a kind of half
stress on the third beat.
Now that is the subtle
difference between 2/4
and 4/4 time.
So a composer has to think,
"Do I want to have a
situation that's a bit binary?
You know, just a strong
beat followed by a weak beat
for my whole piece.
One, two
one, two
strong, weak
strong, weak
It will give you a particular
kind of music character,
wouldn't it?
Or do I want to have fewer
of these stronger stresses
and have something a
little bit more subtle
on three as well?
One
two
three
four
one
two
three
four
So you see how that goes.
Arguably there's even a hierarchy
that goes a bit further,
where you might say that the fourth beat,
because it's the last beat of the bar,
is even lighter than the second beat.
So you could have a kind
of a priority of beats
where number one is the strongest,
followed by number three,
followed by number two,
followed by number four.
If you want to get in the subtly of it.
So rhythmically it doesn't
make any difference,
if you count your way
through a piece of music
that's in two or four time.
They're pretty interchangeable.
But if you listen out for
where the stress comes
you should be able to make out at least
where the first beat is coming.
So is it coming every other beat,
in which case it's in two time.
Or is it just the first of every four,
in which case it's in four time.
So hopefully that explains
the answer to the question.
In a way, theoretically
what is the difference
apart from seeing fewer bar lines
in 4/4 than in 2/4.
Musically, aurally, there is actually
quite a fundamental difference
and it's all about the
stressing of main beats
and being lighter on the weaker beats.
