- [Assistant] Tech Support,
C1, take one, mark.
[clapboard claps]
- Ow![moans]
[woman laughs]
Greetings, everyone.
Bill Nye here once again to
answer your science questions.
This is "Science Support" part three.
[upbeat music]
James Revelle asks, "How
come we know more about space
"than we do about our own ocean?
"I heard that on a doc somewhere."
Well, if you heard it
on a documentary, James,
I guess you're set.
No, okay, there's an old saying
that's it's easier to explore the moon
than the bottom of the ocean.
And that's true for three reasons.
The ocean is cold, it's
crushing, and it's corrosive.
That's why.
It's easier with binoculars
to explore the moon
than it is with a scuba
mask from a department store
to observe the bottom of the ocean.
Carry on, James.
David Blanchflower BSc.
He asks, "Now that tardigrades
have settled on the moon,
"I wonder what their future holds.
"Will they successfully rehydrate?
"Can they flourish?
"In thousands of years
will they build spaceships
"and return to Earth?
"Fascinating."
Oh, there's a picture, he's
got a picture of a tardigrade.
Tardigrades are also
called the water bear.
You can see 'em with your naked eye.
He said naked, oh my god!
The word settled.
I think crash landing in
the harsh vacuum of space
on planetary body that has no
atmosphere or liquid water,
I think that's not the same as settling.
I don't think they're gonna
settle the moon, David.
Carry on.
"Bill Nye, assuming a perfect scenario
"where the general disasters don't occur,
"if the earth stopped spinning,
would we all feel dizzy?
I guess so [laughs].
Not a test you'll probably be able to run.
Toni Philips writes, "A
climate change question.
"As it gets hotter, more
air conditioning is used
"heating up the air even more.
"Is there a way to cool indoor
spaces without heating up
"the outdoors, especially in cities?"
Well, Toni, probably not.
Because what is the one
thing you can count on
in this universe?
That's right, Toni, the
second law of thermodynamics.
Heat just spreads out, man.
So when you pump the heat
out of this room or the room
you're sitting in, putting it outside,
the outside gets a little bit warmer.
But the scale of it,
I hope, surprises you.
The amount of heat we
pump out of buildings
ain't no nothing.
Compared with the amount of
heat that we're holding in
by adding greenhouse gases
to the earth's atmosphere.
The heat island effect
of cities is more from
hardscape paved surfaces.
Buildings are not soil, for example.
And that's why cities are so hot.
The AC thing is a problem,
but it's just the hardscape that gets us,
and that flipping second
law of thermodynamics.
I'm sorry, woman.
There's nothing we can do out there.
We gotta deal.
It's entropy, entropy killing us all.
[sighs]
hala writes, "When will
teleportation happen?"
[laughs] I don't know.
Happens all the time in science fiction.
But that's fiction.
No, just the information problem alone
probably makes teleportation impossible.
Converting something like you into a beam
of electromagnetic signals,
it's very, very unlikely.
Just taking you apart and
putting you back together
would take extraordinary
amounts of energy.
Alyssa asks, "Honestly,
I have a science degree
"and a partially completed doctorate,
"and I still have no idea
what a neutron does."
Okay.
Neutrons give, make things massive, man.
And if you can fuse them
together, you can release
a whole bunch of energy,
which we hope is the future.
Liam asks, "If the mantle
is filled with lava,
"why aren't the oceans boiling or at least
"warmer than they are?"
There's a couple of things.
First of all, that the
oceans are not boiling
and the earth remains very warm inside
is evidence of an aphorism
I hope you will embrace,
a saying, a way of looking at the world
that I hope you, Liam, will take to heart.
If things were any other way,
things would be different.
And here's what we mean by that.
Indeed, the earth does
radiate a large amount,
but relatively small amount of heat,
into the icy blackness of space.
The bottom of the ocean
is the earth's crust.
You gotta go down another 10,
20, 30 kilometers most places
to get to the mantle.
Carry on, Liam.
"Bill Nye, if aliens were
to fly by light years away,
"would they see the
dinosaurs or the Trojan War
"or something since light
they see is so old?"
Yes, they would, Spurkey.
"Bill Nye," this is Drew asks,
"Bill Nye, why does the moon
"reflect in one straight
line when it hits the ocean?"
It may interest you to
know that it reflects
in all different directions
when it hits the ocean.
Just you as the observer
see a straight line.
If you don't believe me,
get your friends to stand
in a line along the beach
where you can call out
to each other and ask each other
if you each see a straight line.
And then ask yourself if they're parallel.
Or if you don't trust your friends,
and I don't blame you,
set up cameras.
Take pictures along a kilometer or two.
Carry on, Drew.
Andrew Ralston says, "Okay,
"okay, I'll say it!
"I'll say it!
"How do planes work?"
And I presume by that,
Andrew, you mean airplanes.
'Cause a carpenter's plane has a blade
and you push it along, the
carpenter pushes it along
and it peels off the wood,
but an airplane works like a bird.
You get the momentum of
air molecules going down
has it produces enough
force to hold the wing up.
And the way you get air
molecules going down
is get the wing going fast.
What about a helicopter?
A helicopter's wings that are spinning.
And the propeller blades,
either the exposed ones
that you might see on what we would call
a propeller aircraft
or the turban blades inside the tubes
on a jet airplane, they're
going around in a circle,
and they're pushing air
molecules back so fast
that they push the airplane forward.
It's not magic, it's science!
Gojirasans asks.
I'm doing my best to pronounce
your name, Gojirasans.
"Bill Nye, if we took all
the animals out of the ocean,
"how much shallower do you
think the oceans would get?
"In other words, how much water
"do you think animals displace?"
I'll bet it's less than you think.
Animals like you and I are mostly water.
Animals that live in the
ocean are almost all water.
I don't think it would change that much.
Since you asked how much do you think,
my answer is not much.
Carry on, Gojirasans.
Drew asks, "Bill Nye, do you
think aliens actually exist?"
So you want to resist making
a joke about my old boss.
[laughs] I don't know if he was an alien.
[clears throat]
There are 200 billion stars in our galaxy,
and there're at least that many galaxies.
When I was in school, it was
speculated that there might be
a planet, a single planet
around one in every 100 stars.
Now with observations from
Hubble Space Telescope,
Kepler Space Telescope,
other inferential methods,
people think there're
probably about 10 planets
around every star.
So that's another factor of a 1,000.
That takes you into the two
trillions in just our galaxy.
If you've got two trillion of anything,
you gotta figure something's gonna happen.
So there probably are aliens.
Do they sit around and
do fabulous and important
Twitter-styled podcasts?
I don't know.
Maybe.
Carry on.
Eroic Enrique, 'cause he says the Hs,
or she says the H is silent.
"Are you an alien, Bill, sent
here to educate the human race
"and save us from our own destruction?"
Yes, I'm an alien.
I've been sent here like the landing party
that that one astronaut
claims he believes in.
No, I'm not an, I'm one of you.
I'm one of us.
We're all in this together.
Linkshallkill89, "Bill
Nye, how does fusion work?
"Do you think we'll be able
to have fusion power plants
"the way we use nuclear
power plants before 2050?"
Fusion works by overcoming what's called
the strong nuclear force or
the strong nuclear interaction.
And I believe it is quite
reasonable we will have fusion,
not by running a stream
of protons into deuterium
or tritium, oh no,
but by running a stream
neutrons into boron hydride gas.
Stay tuned.
KC Cooning writes, "Bill
Nye, I've been fascinated
"and quite obsessed," parenthetically,
"with the alternate
parallel universe theory."
Oh, you know that theory,
that theory about the
alternate parallel universe.
"So my question is this.
"If such a thing were to exist,
would the laws of physics
"necessarily have to apply
to every single universe?"
Well, so here's the thing, KC.
Let's just take history
of physics, for example.
People got by.
They build pyramids.
They discovered round
things roll, made wheels.
All kinds of agriculture was developed
without really formalizing
the laws or rules
of physics or natural laws.
And so people presume that what we called
Newton's laws of motion
were it for centuries.
And it was great.
We made all sorts of progress.
But then relativity was discovered,
then quantum electrodynamics,
and we refined the laws of physics.
People, when your sophomoric
view of the world,
Isaac Newton was wrong.
Isaac was pretty flipping right.
But then as we made more discoveries
about the nature of mass and light
and quantum electrodynamics,
we refined it.
So I presume if another universe exists
and it has what we might call
different laws of physics,
it doesn't mean that our laws of physics
are necessarily wrong.
It just means they're incomplete.
Everyday we learn a little more.
Carry on, KC.
Brian Schmidt asks, "Didn't
I hear we could get to
"the next habitable planet in a few years
"with this space sail?
"Just need a sail the size
of Texas in order to do it?"
Sail the size of Texas
is not gonna take us
to another habitable
planet in a few years,
but solar sails such as
LightSail 2 may revolutionize
space exploration here in the solar system
because we can go to extraordinary speeds
with no rocket fuel.
There's certain missions that
solar sails are ideal for.
Put a solar sails spacecraft
at an inferior orbit
closer to the sun than the earth is,
and keep an eye out for asteroids,
or maybe more importantly,
coronal mass ejections
from the sun which send a
beam of charged particles
slashing through space toward the earth
which could disable many, many
of our communication systems.
So there's certain missions
that solar sails are ideal for,
but a Texas-sized one going
to a nearby habitable planet
is probably not among 'em.
And I remind you that
it's not the solar wind.
It's not particles streaming from the sun
that give a solar sail spacecraft a push.
It is the light itself, photons.
There's about 100 times
more pressure from photons
than charged particles.
Fascinating, I hope.
Carry on, Brian.
"Bill Nye, do insects feel
gravity the same way we do?"
Yes.
The Spiderman does whatever a spider can.
Of course, spiders aren't insects,
but he doesn't do it
because his understanding
of gravity is different.
He does it because he's not real.
Thank you for your questions.
We'll be back with more "Science Support"
number four, coming soon.
And when it does, turn it up loud!
