We've got plenty of calls
so we're gonna start with Liz from Leeds
Liz?
Hello Trisha good morning
what do you want to say?
I'd first like to extend my
solidarity to Ash who is trying to
explain things intellectually
Communism is a human society
it's where we take care of each other
we're not divided by racism
sexism misogyny homophobia
the profit motive no longer rules over us
and we actually establish production on
the basis of human need
it's very very simple
now when Carol talks about
you know the USSR in China and what
have you they were not communist countries
they were counter-revolutionary 
totalitarian dictatorships
tell me where this communism 
that you're talking about works Liz
will you
excuse me Carol
I watched you on Sky News telling 
Afua Hirsch that there was no racism
and she's a black woman
so please allow me to finish
there are no communist countries
 or societies in the world
the Bolshevik Revolution
was smashed to pieces by 14 foreign armies
from Britain, Germany to Japan
that is why that failed
Stalin was a counter revolutionary 
totalitarian dictator
no you can't vote communism in
you build communism through our
collective human struggles
I'm gonna ask you to hold it there Liz
only because we're gonna run
out of time quick reply from Carole
and then we I just asked her where communism
works today it's not working in any country
