- There are very few things about me
that are similar to an NBA player.
For one I'm 5'4", but today
I have at least one thing
in common with a professional
basketball player.
I'm wearing this Smart Ring.
The NBA has bought 2000 of these rings,
which are made by Oura Health,
as part of their COVID-19 safety plan.
The league offered them to players
in the anti COVID-19
bubble at Disney world,
where they'll finish
the rest of the season.
Inside the bubble, the
NBA is using the rings
to predict if someone might
be developing symptoms
of an illness, like COVID-19.
The problem is, there's
no proof that predicting
any disease, including COVID-19,
via wearables is possible, yet.
- [James] We simply don't
know enough right now.
- [Nicole] That's James Gilmore,
a wearable technologies
researcher at Clemson university.
- [James] A lot of the reporting
that's happening around
the NBA's decision risks
inflating this wearable ring
into this sort of mystical object,
that anybody can buy, and
anybody can use to, you know,
see if they're gonna have COVID-19 or not,
which is not the case,
based on the understanding
that we have today.
- The Oura Ring monitors
things like heart rate,
steps, body temperature, and sleep.
The theory is that subtle
changes in those measures
can detect illness before
you even feel sick.
NBA players who choose to use the ring,
will have their data
shipped off to researchers
at the University of Michigan.
Those scientists will produce
an illness probability
score for each player.
If they think the data indicates
that someone could be sick,
they'll be flagged for
additional COVID-19 testing.
- [James] The NBA's also said
that they're gonna be testing people
pretty much every day,
which to me, makes me ask,
so what's the point of the Oura Ring,
except for just kind of
running an experiment.
- The idea that wearable
technology could predict illness
has been floating around for years.
It isn't new with COVID-19.
For a while now, researchers
have been working with
devices like Fitbits, and Apple watches.
There are anecdotal stories
about people who see changes
in their wearable data just
before they start to feel sick.
And previous research found
that there are certain patterns
in that data that tend to appear
before people with Lyme
disease start showing symptoms.
Oura started looking
into illness prediction
after seeing a Facebook post from a user.
Oura's CEO, Harpreet Rai told
me how it all played out.
- [Harpreet] He happened to
be traveling the week before,
and he opens his app up, and it says,
Hey, your readiness score is 54,
and it looks like you're
actually getting a temperature.
He then starts to think like, wow,
I've never gotten a score that low,
and he didn't even feel any symptoms.
He describes himself as asymptomatic.
He's like, you know what? I was traveling.
I was in Austria, and it looks like
there was one COVID case there.
Now I'm gonna get tested, and
he ended up being positive.
- So, the company pivoted
to disease prediction.
Two ongoing studies at the
University of California,
San Francisco, and at
West Virginia University,
are checking to see if data from the ring,
along with symptom surveys,
and AI models can actually predict
that someone is getting sick, in general.
They'll also see if it can
predict COVID-19 specifically,
but the NBA placed an order for the rings
before there were any published studies
proving that they worked,
which isn't surprising to experts.
This isn't the first
time a pro sports league
has turned to an unproven
wearable tech solution.
Athletes and pro sports leagues
have previously turned to devices
that are big on flash, but
fuzzier on substance before.
A quick tech fix is appealing,
but it's especially
appealing to elite athletes.
We're always striving for a
sliver of competitive edge.
(high intensity techno music)
Back in 2016, a device
called the halo sport
was popular with NFL
players and other athletes.
It sends a stimulating
current into the motor cortex
of the wearer's brain.
After wearing it for 20
minutes during your warmup,
it claims to help people
build physical skills
and develop muscle memory more quickly.
So it would make training
a physical skill,
like throwing a football, more efficient.
Some athletes felt like it helped them.
And there's some studies, mostly in mice,
showing that this type
of electrical stimulation
of the brain can prime it for learning.
It's a plausible theory,
but it hadn't been proven
by the time the NFL
started using the halo device.
Another wearable device called the Whoop,
is also used by dozens of pro athletes.
Like an Oura Ring, it monitors
things like heart rate,
and sleep, and says it's algorithms
can help people optimize their
workouts and their recovery.
It claims that wearers
have fewer injuries,
and a lower resting heart rate.
There hasn't been much
independent evaluation
to say if using the Whoop
actually does help people
improve their performance,
but that didn't stop the
NFL Players Association
from naming it an official
recovery wearable.
Tech like this is appealing,
because it offers easy
solutions to complex problems.
If strapping on a wearable can tell you
how much sleep you need to get,
to get the most out of
your workout the next day,
that sounds pretty good.
At the highest level of sport,
the difference between the
best and the worst athlete
can come down to millimeters.
Everyone is interested in
trying anything they can
to chip away at those gaps.
For the past decade,
people have increasingly
relied on science and data
to push performance forward.
- [James] We seem to be
increasingly interested
in athletes' data.
And this is something that is true
of their performance during the game.
It's true of the coaches and trainers
who are developing those athletes.
It's true of how the athletes
internalize themselves.
They kind of become a
testing ground for devices
that can measure different
elements of athlete data
to try and improve their performance.
- But there are risks when that data
comes from unproven products.
In a 2016 paper, sports scientists warned
that wearables that aren't fully validated
could cause anxiety for athletes.
They might push out data
that isn't quite accurate,
and people may make changes
based on those numbers.
There are also privacy issues at stake.
Pro athletes definitely
don't want information
on their physical health
being used in contract
negotiations against them.
- [James] When the Players'
Association formed,
they actually created
a wearables committee
that was designed for the players
to work on developing protocols in a way
that would help the players
learn from the devices
while sort of shielding that data
from being gobbled up by the organization.
- To be clear, the NBA
has protections in place
around the ring data.
Coaches can't see it.
When a league like the NBA
uses something like the Oura Ring,
it boosts the credibility of the products
before we actually have the research
to know if that's warranted.
The Oura team knows this
is still experimental.
The product wasn't designed
to be an illness prediction
tool, but during the pandemic,
anything that can pivot to COVID-19 will,
and that ups the stakes.
- [James] The tricky
issue here is because Oura
has entered into sort of this COVID-19
sort of solutionism framework,
it runs the risk of people buying it,
thinking that it's going to tell them
when they are experiencing
COVID-19 related symptoms,
but I don't think that it can do that
right out of the box.
- Oura isn't explicitly making any claims
about the device's ability
to predict anything.
They're more suggesting
it's a possibility,
based on what they've seen so far,
but the case of the Oura user
who saw a change in their data
before they tested
positive is just a story.
It takes a lot more evidence to prove
that something is actually
predicting an illness.
Wearable advocates argue though,
that getting more information
about your body is good.
People might still be
able to see a relationship
between their own personal stats,
and when they start to feel ill.
But really, this is all
just one big experiment.
Sports leagues like to experiment,
and experiments are good.
They help give us important
critical information,
but they also come with risks.
When we filmed this video,
there weren't any major
outbreaks inside the NBA bubbles.
So I guess sticking a
bunch of people in a hotel
and testing them every
day, actually works.
Thanks for watching, and be sure to follow
the rest of our coronavirus
coverage at theverge.com.
